I can't get my head around this bit at all.
If I bought and sold a car after three years, yes the depreciation may be slightly more than the rent, but I would have the money back from selling the car whereas you would have nothing to show for your three years worth of rent?
£20000 - £10000 = £10000 = -£10000 assuming £20k cash purchase and 10k resale.
£0 - £10000 = -£10000 assuming £10k lease fees and an empty bank account to begin with.
So it's decent if you don't have the cash to begin with and want / need a new car.
This.
I haven't got the cash flow to spend £30k on a car, nor do I want to save up for a long time to get that pot of cash. Furthermore if I did have £30k lying around I would be investing it in something that is going to appreciate rather than throwing it away on a car.
On the other hand, just because I dont have that £30k to hand doesn't mean that I'm too poor to own an expensive car - it just means I'd rather divert my savings elsewhere, yet drive a car which I feel is appropriate.
It may well be a bit cheaper to buy the car outright and sell it after 2 years making a lot of money back, but I'd need to get a £30k loan in order to buy it... Which is gonna be close to £1k a month over 5 years.
Your posts don't make sense.
If you actually had £30k, you wouldn't spend it on a car. But instead your going to 'rent' a car that you'll never see ANY return on??
Also, £1k a month over 60 months is £60k, you need to find a cheaper loan provider
Heh heh, I didn't add it up as I was eating my tea but it would be more like £650 a month which is still high.
The only way to get any ROI on a car is to either keep it for a long time, or pay more upfront/monthly - neither of which I want to do. If I thought I'd still be driving the same car in 5-6 years I'd obviously be looking to buy, but I won't be.
Even with used cars you get stung heavily on depreciation... My previous zed, I bought it for 13.5k and sold it for 8k... That's 5.5k lost in 2.5 years. For the same money I cold have been in a brand new merc on PCP.