Its a real pain.
We have an industry wide pension, for the few that are left. With the numbers contributing going down every year the lag of members claiming still increases. This causes a constant shortfall which needs topping up. I pay a lot more per month and my employer pays a hell of a lot more. They recently had to pay another one off top up fee of 2K per head.
I dont think there is any quick fix. Even if you were to take the money out it and try to invest yourself its hard to see how you would get a good return. It looks like evryone is doing the buy t let game now.
Thanks to the government taxing pension plans and putting no realistic legislation in place to stop companies abusing its access to this money its a very unfair lottery.
As for tax. I have been PAYE and done self employed work at the same time for many years. I was always striaght with my returns but gave up working on leave a few years ago as the accountance fees were outweighing the income due to constant battles with the tax man.
I am very lucky in having a final salary pension scheme. Its just a matter of wether it goes bankrupt before I get there.
Dont think there are any easy answers bud, its the best of a bad system at the moment.