Pretty much because it didn't try and oversteer at every single corner. Whilst the fact that the 'Yota does like to have it's arse hanging out all the time is probably half of the appeal, I much preferred the way the stiffer front springs on the Scoob allowed the front end to tuck in quicker. This meant you could get back on the power earlier and ring the neck out of the engine, and since that's exactly what you need to do to make progress it seemed like the way to go. The interior is slightly less awful in the BRZ too. We did come very close to buying the BRZ but the numbers just didn't stack up in the end.
Anyone who thinks that 200bhp isn't plenty enough for the roads probably needs to learn how to drive
Thanks Dan - very interesting and, in principle, I prefer the sound of the characteristics you describe. How did you find the ride quality - how did it deal with bumps and ruts particularly mid corner? Sorry if bit OT for original OP.