The heading says it all really. Please nominate cars that exceeded, fell short of or well met your expectations one way or another. This, as you can imagine, is not a factual thing....it's more to do with what was in your mind beforehand. Also it might be that you drove a rogue (or saintly) example?
I will kick off:
Better - Alfa 145 QV (in UK Green Cloverleaf). Everyone had said "all Alfas are now rubbish". The engine was a gem, the handling was much better than I expected (albeit with some body roll) and it never broke down. A great 2 years.
Worse - Z3M Roadster. I had been told that the M version addressed the issues with the standard Z3. One of the most disappointing drives - almost devoid of feel. Didn't finish the test drive. Bought 350Z.
Met (bad) - My Dad bought an FSO Polonez. No further narrative necessary.
Met (good) - Caterham 7