It’s a shame that there doesn’t seem to have been a counter argument from a “religious intellectualâ€.
Anyway....
My father became a Priest later in life (after having served initially in the Navy and then later going on to become a senior Police Officer). In between he somehow managed to pass his bar exams, wrote several textbooks, founded a male voice choir – amongst other things. Anyway, as far as I could tell he wasn’t thick. It’s a shame he is no longer here to put his side of the argument because I would find it difficult to do so. Anyway, my point is that there seems to be a largish number of people who appear to be highly intelligent and yet still believe.....it would be good to hear from someone like that.
My early life had a large input from the Cof E and my recollection of it was pretty positive i.e. the emphasis on trying to be a good person and treating others as you would wish to be treated. Mine was a benign education in the sense that it wasn’t rammed down my throat. I stopped going to church in my late teens and I can never remember my father trying to persuade me (I think his view was that “push†needed to come from me).
The things I found difficult were the gap between what people professed to believe and their behavior in day-to-day life and how few of them used to do anything to actually make a difference in the real world – my Dad used to say “too heavenly to be any earthly goodâ€. Later, I found it frustrating and sometimes amusing the extent to which the church tried to become “trendyâ€, but without much social leadership when it gets down and dirty. It reminds of the modern politician who tries to work out what everyone wants and then miraculously believes in that.