Interesting thread, very similar views as were on my thread a few months ago http://www.350z-uk.c...something-else/
I'm still totally torn what to do! I'm getting frustrated now as I hate not having a car!
My situation is a little different as I work away for a few weeks at a time so will be in the garage, then when I'm home for a few weeks would need to be usable daily. That rules out a classic for me, or I would seriously consider a 67-69 Camero or 240/250z. It also rules out Cobras etc as it needs to be usable all year in all weather.
Investment wise it'd be a TVR or Porsche 911. but the missus hates both of them unfortunately.
Yesterday I test drove a Stage1 GT-R and I have to admit I was blown away how good it was! I really didn't expect to like it as much as I did and I'm now VERY tempted by one.
A few days before I drove the Aston 4.3 V8 Vantage. It was lovely, really classy, lovely nose (of course), quality interior and handled really well on the b-roads. I was impressed. It felt really special. However, it definitely lacked some low-end torque but I thought I might be able to live with it as having to rev the V8 to get full benefit was worth it.
I wrote about my Maserati 4.2 Granturismo test in my thread above.
My thoughts at the moment are if spending up to £35k it'll be the Aston. 35k - 45k = GT-R or 4.7 Granturismo. I just need to try the 4.7 Maser now then make a final decision. lol
GT-R is winning right now though so if the right one came up I'd probably jump.